A Review of the Relative Value of Fleet Ships (Tiers 4 & 5)
Unfortunately I wasn't able to fit my review of all 5 tiers of Fleet Ships in one post, so here's a second one. To look at how my rating system works or to see tiers 1-3, click the link below:
Anyway, since this thread is just a continuation of the first one, I'll just jump right in.
=== KDF Tier 4 ===
Benchmark: Hegh'Ta Bird-of-Prey
The Hoh'Sus Bird-of-Prey is a ship that performs very similarly to the Hegh'Ta, but it has noticeably better firepower. Have a look:
Pros: +1 Tactical Console.
Cons: -1 Engineering Console, -6% Hull, -25% Crew.
An extra tactical console means that the Hoh'Sus has almost the same offensive power as a Qin Raptor (it just has one aft weapon less). However this comes at the cost of an engineering console; this combined with the reduced hull rating means that this BoP has less staying power than a Hegh'Ta. Win or lose, whatever fight you are in with this ship is going to be over faster than with the Hegh'Ta.
If you like flying Birds-of-Prey but wish that they had more punch then this one should definitely be on your shopping list (unless you plan on getting the Fleet version - see below). On the other hand, if you find the lack of durability of a Bop to be frustrating then you probably shouldn't bother with this one.
I was tempted to give this one a **** rating, and it should probably be about 3.5 stars instead of 3, though I wanted to stick with whole numbers. The loss of the 6% hull isn't that drastic, but when combined with the loss of an engineering console it makes for a noticable drop in survivability. If the Hoh'Sus gave up a science console instead of engineering it definitely would have been **** in my books. Of course, if you fly BoPs as a Sci officer then this probably doesn't appeal to you either way.
Fleet Hoh'Sus Bird-of-Prey
Benchmark: Hegh'Ta Bird-of-Prey
The Fleet Hoh'Sus Bird-of-Prey is essentially an up-gunned Hegh'Ta. It gets an extra tactical console and doesn't really lose anything in the exchange:
Pros: +1 Tactical Console, +3% Hull, +10% Shields.
Cons: -25% Crew.
The loss of 25% of your crew is no big deal, and meanwhile this BoP is more durable than the Hegh'Ta and the extra tac console means a significant increase in firepower. I know I am comparing this to a free ship and you have to pay to get it, but if I had made a comparison this good against a paid ship it would be five stars instead of four.
You might disagree if you don't want a BoP to be a damage-dealing ship. If you use a BoP as a science or engineering ship (having all universal slots allows that) then you should probably consider this to be a *** since the extra tactical console doesn't help you that much. But if you want a BoP with maximum DPS then this ship is definitely the one you want.
Fleet Negh'Var Retrofit
Benchmark: Negh'Var Battlecruiser
Once again I'm comparing a paid ship to a free ship, which I don't like to do. But here the Negh'Var is the most obvious comparison. And though I'm not a big fan of the base Negh'Var, this ship is a nice change over the original:
Pros: +1 Engineering Console, +10% Shields, +10% Hull, Engineering Ensign bridge slot upgraded to Universal.
The fact the the KDF's primary tank ship gets an extra engineering console and extra points in shield and hull makes this ship the KDF's #1 tank ship. It now has more shields than a Bortas'Qu and only slightly less hull.
But what really makes this ship stand out is the universal bridge slot. You can put an engineer there and fly it like a regular Negh'Var, or a tac officer and fly it like a Vor'Cha, or you could put a science officer there and fly it like a Mirror Universe battlecruiser. Suddenly all these other ship types become superfluous. If you like flying cruisers and want flexibility then this ship is definitely the ship for you. The only other ship that can compete is the Tor'Kaht which is a tactical/engineering hybrid. This ship is definitely an engineering ship first, but it can be used in a variety of ways.
=== KDF Tier 5 ===
Fleet Vo'Quv Carrier
Benchmark: Vo'Quv Carrier
The Fleet Vo'Quv follows the same pattern as all the other ships which are a Fleet version of a level 40 free ship: more hull, shields, and one extra console:
Pros: +1 Tactical Console, +10% Hull, +10% Shields.
It's unfortunate that the extra console is a tactical console, which doesn't do the Vo a whole lot of good since fighter damage is AFAIK not affected by consoles. Not that an extra console is bad; you can always put universal consoles there if you have any. But overall, though we do get an improvement over the Vo'Quv, you do have to pay $20 to get it, so I rate this ship as average. But if you have a Vo and love it then you should consider shelling out the $20 for this one.
On the other hand, if PWE ever makes a tac console that specifically improves fighter attacks then I would definitely change the rating of this ship to ****.
Bortas Cruiser Retrofit
Benchmark: Bortas'Qu Cruiser
Most of the fleet vessels are improvements over existing ships, but not the Bortas. Instead, the Bortas is a way for free players to fly a ship that normally you have to shell out $25 bucks for. So as a free version of a paid ship, you might expect that this ship would not be as good as the paid version... if you did, you'd be right:
Cons: -1 Console (type depending on configuration), no special abilities, Universal Ensign Bridge Slot downgraded to Engineering.
The Bortas'Qu is actually three different ships (one for each career type), and each one of those ships has a unique ability and an extra console slot based on career type, so basically we just lose those abilities as well as the universal Ensign slot (which becomes engineering).
Nevertheless the Bortas still has a universal Lt. Commander bridge slot, and a console configuration with four tac and four eng consoles, so it can tank well or attack well. The only problem is that it has a horribly low turn rate compared to other cruisers, which reduces your effective weapon choices, but then so does the Bortas'Qu. Overall I rate this ship as average. But if you always wanted a Bortas'Qu but didn't want to pay for it, this is how you get one.
Well, that's all the KDF fleet ships that I know about. Hope you enjoyed the review!
I'm interested in your take of the Fleet Norgh vrs the Fleet Hoh'Sus
The stats specifically seem to make little sense when considering the base Norg, and I'm presently of the belief that the stats for the Fleet Norg, Fleet Hoh'Sus and Hoh'Sus are jumbled. It appears to me that the Fleet Norg should be taking the Fleet Hoh'Sus stats, the Fleet Hoh'sus the Hoh'Sus stats and the Hoh'Sus the Fleet Norg stats.
As far as the fleet raider I don't see one tac console and slight buffs to defense being worth 2k zpoints. Compared to high damage escorts it still lacks a rear weapon mount and a tac console even w/the 1 added for high damage design fed/jem ships. It has one less ens boff as well too. To make it worthwhile it should gain a rear weapon or an ens boff and make it available at T4 base (personally I think the rear weapon mount).
Off topic the other Fleet BoP looks interesting, but the survivablility (16k base hull HP and severely reduced shield modifier) is so diminished I don't know if it's worth spending the Z-points to try it out.
In general the KDF escort/raider options are continually falling farther behind to lotto ships and fed counterparts in damage potential. While DPS cruisers and the Karfi still hold there own and then some in the case of the Karfi, they still don't fill the damage role of an escort/raider. My main concern is as KDF style of raiding falls farther behind in damage potential the flavor of playing KDF becomes less unique and that KvF will turn into lotto ship vs lotto ship fed circle the wagons style fights.
The Fleet Hoh'sus has an improvement in stats over the Hegh'Ta and also has a bonus tac console, so if you are using a BoP as a tactical ship then it is a decent buy. And though it's firepower is not quite as high as a Qin it does have that awesomely high turn rate.
I would like to see the stats for the Norgh beefed up and it is possible that PWE may do this. Likewise I feel that the K'T'Ingas need beefing up as do the Somraws, and the Scourge could use a small tweak of improvement.
Frankly if the K'T'Inga retrofit stats were simply identical to the Vor'Cha I probably would get one because I love how it looks. But considering how badly it performs compared to a Vor'Cha I won't be bothering. The same idea applies with the Norgh, although the Boff layout change at least gives you some kind of reason to buy one. But I might end up getting the Fleet Hoh'Sus. It is not #1 on my list but it is at least on it.
|All times are GMT -7. The time now is 03:48 PM.|