Star Trek Online

Star Trek Online (
-   Star Trek Online General Discussion (
-   -   Isn't STO really a FPS, not a mmorpg? (

Archived Post 01-31-2010 11:38 AM

Isn't STO really a FPS, not a mmorpg?
This game really meets the conventional architecture of a fps as opposed to a mmorpg, as defined by Cryptic, the more I play it.

STO is a rudimentary space shooter.

*Space is, by their design are nothing more than small, confining shoe-boxes of many instances.

*Space is segmented into these life-less nodes of rooms with 4-walls, a floor and ceiling.

*pve and pvp combat consists of a frag-fest of no contributory game-play reward or consequences.

*Like a simple fps mapping content system, the space and ground combat has the most limiting, redundant, counter-strike fps pve of any game in the genre.

*Again, like a fps pvp match without any game-play contributory value, other than winning a map, it amounts to targeting an enemy, gun at that enemy, kill said enemy, rinse, and repeat without any contributing game-play value, other than points toward character progression.

*Your rewarded as much for winning as losing. There are no consequences for loss, but a huge win of respawning immediately close to the frag-fest action to do it all over again.

*Rpg is non-existant since all map points and personal wins are based on ‘damage-output or kills’, and without anyone playing a role as a science officer or engineer being recognized or rewarded for healing or shielding, for example; everything favors the tactician role only of damage.

*Exploration mmorpg style doesn’t exist, so there’s no freedom of exploration. No exploration to other planets or discovery; again, your confined to your shoe-box instance, fps style without anything dynamically to do. There is no away-team capability to freely explore the surface of a planet, which is essentially an inanimate marble, in a shoe-box instance.

*As with a limiting fps lobby system of maps, content is sorely lacking to the point where very very early on in this game, the 'instanced' pve quests are nothing more than similar repeatable maps and mobs of previous quests/maps done.

*As with a fps lobby system game, the massively is missing from mmorpg where community feels fragmented to one of those several small instanced zones that does nothing to encourage the feel of massively multiplayer entertainment.

Archived Post 01-31-2010 11:42 AM

Do you understand the concept behind a mmorpg or mmog.

Archived Post 01-31-2010 11:44 AM

There is absolutely no reason why an FPS can't be an MMORPG, I don't really get your point? But no, you never see this game from a first person prespective, only third person.

Archived Post 01-31-2010 11:45 AM

Let's call it: A Third Person Shooter! :D

Archived Post 01-31-2010 11:53 AM

mmorpg does have a much broader delivery of depth and breadth of game-play that seems substantially more dynamic and immersive than a fps, so by the static nature of the single role-play (tactician), repetitive nature of the same quests on the same limited lobby-system maps, STO really is more of a fps.

Thats is only accentuated, the fps feel of this game, by the complete lack of any persistence to this world, which the OP forgot to mention.

But what does kill me, is that there are absolutely no rewards for science officers or engineers to be recognized for in the fps pvp lobby matches.

Archived Post 01-31-2010 11:54 AM

So how do you call a game a First Person Shooter if you're looking the Third Person View?

Archived Post 01-31-2010 11:55 AM

Based on this reasoning EVE is also a FPS (Well in the same way - Third person shooter)

Archived Post 01-31-2010 11:57 AM

Sadly it seems STO is nothing but an arcade space-shooter, the only motivation to play is to get the next tier ship. That. Is. It.

Archived Post 01-31-2010 11:57 AM

Its an MMO....kind of.

Just not a very good one.

Archived Post 01-31-2010 11:59 AM


Originally Posted by Bigwig (Post 1822164)
Sadly it seems STO is nothing but an arcade space-shooter, the only motivation to play is to get the next tier ship. That. Is. It.

u can sum every game that way if you want.

All times are GMT -7. The time now is 07:12 AM.