View Single Post
Join Date: Dec 2007
08-21-2009, 11:33 PM
Originally Posted by
To be honest, I don't like this.
There are quite a few things wrong with this, if we assume its a borg complex. The cubes are too small, based on the scale of the ship there. The supports are extraneous, and really unnecessary with a borg complex, and same for the giant 100m wide pipes. They make no sense, unless the construction of borg cubes and complexes has changed in the last 30 years of the game. And finally, every cube seems to have a different "decoration" on it, like some artist decided to differentiate them. They are borg. They are not individual or unique!
This is, frankly, a bad picture on those aspects alone. Add in the mysterious diffuse lighting, the lack of contrast, details, bump mapping, and its not so hot on an aesthetic front.
Which is not to say, I don't appreciate you doing this Rekhan, but it just wasn't the best to show off! I do appreciate this.
On the one hand:
On the other hand
I think the second looks really good, since that's not a cube. It's just something, possibly Borg... and it looks perfectly practical and mechanical and possibly a little random, but in Borg-useful-like-randomness.