Last I checked, LOTRO is still going quite strong. SWTOR can't pull the massive following required to stay P2P. WoW is limited F2P, in case you hadn't noticed.
And, agian, you missed my point: EVE and WOW can afford to remain P2P because they have (1) a massive following and (2) have a staff and budget entirely dedicated to that project because they are the ONLY MMO made by their respective studios.
If the F2P model fails so hard.....why are so many companies going to it then?
Your argument fails. When you can lay out a better argument rather than parroting the same numbers over and over again, I might be compelled to listen.