I would not necessarily call SWTOR a loss, but for me it had some issues. Others didn't seem to have them at all. Every time there was an interactive conversation, I would get a Server Error and be bumped back to the server selection screen. The gameplay was pretty good.
In any case, I am committed to this game or I would not have bought a lifetime membership. I will consider a subscription to SWTOR only if my in-game time increases enough to allow for two games. At the moment, it does not.