I certainly don't hate it. But I treated it more like as I would a Series of Seaquest DSV - could be Startrek, but just stepped over itself time and time again.
I was a fan of Phlox and of how the series tried to explore the foundations of the Federation with the core races being so known and yet so unknown (such as how they portrayed the Vulcans). I never really fell into step with the future cold war plot, or even the Xindi arc. I would have preferred more 'frontier, new worlds' shtick!